Who Owned Narsil? The 7,000-Year History Before Aragorn
When we watch Peter Jackson's The Lord of the Rings or read J.R.R. Tolkien’s masterpiece, our eyes are often drawn to the moment Aragorn reveals the reforged blade, Andúril. It is the symbol of the Return of the King. But have you ever stopped to wonder about the shattered shards that laid in Rivendell for 3,000 years?
Narsil is not just a broken heirloom; it is a survivor of two apocalypses.
Many fans assume Narsil was simply "Elendil’s sword." However, digging into the deep lore of the First and Second Ages reveals a much more complex lineage. Who forged this blade? How did it survive the drowning of continents? And why does a sword made by a Dwarf look so Elvish?
In this deep dive, we will trace the lineage of the most famous sword in Middle-earth history, answering the question: Who originally owned Narsil before it transformed into Andúril for Aragorn?
Table of Contents
Who Originally Owned Narsil Before It Transformed into Andúril for Aragorn? – LOTR Lore
To understand the ownership of Narsil, we must travel back to a time long before Aragorn, before Sauron forged the One Ring, and even before the island of Númenor existed.
The True Creator: A Masterpiece of the Dwarves
Contrary to the elegant, leaf-shaped design that looks distinctly Elvish in the films, Narsil was actually forged by a Dwarf. But this was not just any smith.
Narsil was created in the First Age by Telchar of Nogrod. Telchar was renowned as one of the greatest smiths in the history of Middle-earth, arguably second only to Fëanor (creator of the Silmarils). His workshop was in the Blue Mountains (Ered Luin), a place that still existed in the west of Middle-earth during the time of The Hobbit.
💡 Lore Note: Telchar's Resume
Telchar didn't just make Narsil. He is responsible for some of the most legendary items in the lore:
- Angrist: The knife Beren used to cut a Silmaril from Morgoth's iron crown.
- The Dragon-helm of Dor-lómin: The legendary helm worn by Turin Turambar.
The name Narsil is crafted from the High-elven tongue, Quenya. It combines 'Nar' (Fire) and 'Thil' (White Light). This symbolizes the sun and the moon, representing the enemies of darkness. The fact that a Dwarf smith named a sword in Quenya suggests the deep friendship and trade that existed between the Dwarves of Nogrod and the Elves of Beleriand during that era.
How Did Narsil Survive the First Age?
The First Age ended in cataclysm. The War of Wrath against Morgoth resulted in the sinking of Beleriand, the western continent. Most great weapons and cities were lost beneath the waves. So, how did Narsil survive?
While Tolkien never explicitly detailed the hand-to-hand transfer, it is widely accepted by lore scholars that Narsil was gifted to the Elves, likely the Noldor, who appreciated Telchar's craft. It eventually found its way into the hands of Elros Tar-Minyatur, the first King of Númenor and brother to Elrond.
Unlike his brother Elrond who chose immortality, Elros chose a mortal life and led the Edain (Men) to the island of Númenor. He took Narsil with him across the sea, marking the sword's survival of its first apocalypse.
The Heirlooms of the Faithful: From Númenor to Middle-earth
This is where the ownership history gets interesting. Narsil was not the primary sword of the Kings of Númenor. The Kings wielded a sword called Aranrúth (originally Thingol's sword).
So, who owned Narsil? It descended through the line of Silmariën.
Silmariën was the eldest child of the fourth King of Númenor. However, the laws at the time did not allow a woman to rule, so the throne passed to her younger brother. Instead of the crown, Silmariën received the Lords of Andúnië lordship and several heirlooms, including the Ring of Barahir and, crucially, Narsil.
The Symbol of the "Faithful"
As the Second Age progressed, the Kings of Númenor grew corrupt, fearing death and envying the Elves. They turned against the Valar. However, the Lords of Andúnië remained the leaders of the "Faithful" (the Elendili)—those who kept the friendship with the Elves alive.
Narsil was passed down through this noble, yet non-ruling, line for generations until it reached Amandil, the last Lord of Andúnië, and finally his son, Elendil.
When Sauron corrupted Númenor, causing its destruction (the Akallabêth), Elendil escaped on nine ships. He brought with him the White Tree seedling, the Ring of Barahir, and Narsil. Narsil survived its second continental destruction, arriving in Middle-earth to found the Kingdoms of Gondor and Arnor.
The Breaking of the Sword: Elendil’s Last Stand
In the late Second Age, during the War of the Last Alliance, Elendil wielded Narsil against Sauron on the slopes of Mount Doom. The lore tells us that Narsil shone with the light of the sun and moon, striking fear into the Orcs.
However, as depicted in the prologue of the films, Elendil fell. As he fell, the sword broke beneath him. It shattered into two pieces (or many shards, depending on the text/film version). His son, Isildur, used the "hilt-shard" to cut the One Ring from Sauron's hand.
From that moment on, the Shards of Narsil became more than a weapon. They became a symbol of a broken lineage waiting to be restored.
| Era | Owner/Wielder | Key Event |
|---|---|---|
| First Age | Telchar (Creator) | Forged in Nogrod |
| Early Second Age | Elros Tar-Minyatur | Brought to Númenor |
| Mid Second Age | Silmariën & Lords of Andúnië | Kept by the Faithful |
| Late Second Age | Elendil the Tall | Escaped Downfall, War of Alliance |
| Third Age | Isildur -> Heirs of Arnor | Preserved as Shards in Rivendell |
| End of Third Age | Aragorn Elessar | Reforged as Andúril |
FAQ: Common Questions About Narsil
Conclusion:
Narsil is a thread that binds the history of Middle-earth together. It started in the forges of a Dwarf in the First Age, sailed the seas of Númenor, survived the wrath of the Valar, and broke in the face of Sauron. Its journey to becoming Andúril is the ultimate story of resilience—a promise that what is broken can be made whole again.
Do you think the movie version of the sword did justice to its book history? Let me know in the comments below!
